Topline
The University of Pennsylvania became the third high-profile university to turn down the Trump administration’s “Compact For Academic Excellence in Higher Education”—a deal that offers special funding advantages for schools that make policy changes aligned with President Donald Trump’s education agenda.
Penn turned down the compact Thursday. (Photo by Erica Denhoff/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)
Icon Sportswire via Getty Images
Key Facts
Penn president J. Larry Jameson said in a brief letter Thursday the university declined to sign the compact.
Jameson said Penn “provided focused feedback highlighting areas of existing alignment as well as substantive concerns.”
Penn’s rejection of the compact comes just one day after Brown University president Christina H. Paxson declined the deal in a letter to federal officials, saying in a statement its “various provisions would restrict academic freedom and undermine the autonomy of Brown’s governance, critically compromising our ability to fulfill our mission.”
Paxson noted Brown’s recent $50 million settlement with the Trump administration to unfreeze federal funds and squash discrimination allegations against it, saying the terms of the settlement advance “a number of the high-level principles articulated in the Compact.”
Paxson also said the settlement also affirms “the government’s lack of authority to dictate our curriculum or the content of academic speech—a principle that is not reflected in the Compact.”
Paxson said a cover letter describing the compact floats the idea of funding university research on the Trump administration’s own criteria instead of “the soundness and likely impact of research.”
Get Forbes Breaking News Text Alerts: We’re launching text message alerts so you’ll always know the biggest stories shaping the day’s headlines. Text “Alerts” to (201) 335-0739 or sign up here.
What Schools Were Initially Offered The Compact?
In addition to Penn, Brown and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, all of which have rejected the deal, the compact was also sent to The University of Arizona, Dartmouth College, the University of Texas, the University of Southern California, Vanderbilt University and the University of Virginia. The University of Texas said it was “honored” to receive the offer, though the school has not committed to it.
What Does The Compact Ask Schools To Change?
The compact offers funding advantages in exchange for policy changes that align with the president’s agenda. The compact notably asks for the removal of or changes to university departments that “purposefully punish, belittle, and even spark violence against conservative ideas.” The deal demands a five-year freeze on tuition, a cap on international student enrollment, SAT requirements for applicants and a ban against the use of race and sex in hiring and admissions processes. It also asks universities to adhere to the government’s binary definition of gender and apply it to restrooms and sports.
What To Watch For
The Trump administration reportedly sent the compact to all higher education institutions after MIT turned it down, according to Bloomberg, becoming the first school to do so.
Key Background
The Trump administration’s push for colleges to agree to its compact follows a wide-ranging attack against federal funding for some of the country’s most prestigious universities. As part of a sweeping antisemitism investigation linked to pro-Palestinian protests on several campuses last year, the administration froze billions of dollars in funding for schools including Brown, Columbia University, Harvard University, Cornell University, Princeton University and the University of California Los Angeles. Institutions like Columbia and Brown agreed to settlements to get their funding back, with the former university agreeing to pay $221 million and make changes to some of its protest, security and educational policies. Penn settled with the government and agreed to ban transgender athletes from women’s sports after the Education Department alleged Title IX violations.
Further Reading
MIT ‘Cannot Support’ Trump’s Compact—First University To Reject Funding Deal (Forbes)
Newsom Says California Will Cut Funds For ‘Sell-Out Universities’ Complying With Trump Education Crackdown (Forbes)
